It’s not really a STEM gender gap, but a ‘TE’ gender gap

by Grace

Randy Olson graphed the percentage of bachelor’s degrees conferred to women by major.

20140617.COCSTEMDegreesWomen1

The only STEM gender gaps are in computer science and engineering.

Surprisingly to me, most of the STEM majors aren’t doing as bad gender disparity-wise as I expected. 40-45% of the degrees in Math, Statistics, and the Physical Sciences were conferred to women in 2012. Even better, a majority of Biology degrees in 2012 (58%) were earned by women. This data tells me that we don’t really have a STEM gender gap in the U.S.: we have an ET gender gap!

If we actually have a shortage in skilled engineering and technology employees, this gender gap matters.

This ET gender gap has severe consequences. Computer Science and Engineering majors have stagnated at less than 10% of all degrees conferred in the U.S. for the past decade, while the demand for employees with programming and engineering skills continue to outpace the supply every year…

Provided that far more women attend college than men, it seems the best way to meet the U.S.’s growing need for skilled programmers and engineers is to focus on recruiting more women — of any race or ethnicity — into Computer Science and Engineering majors. The big question, of course, is “How?” With the constant issues of subtle (and sometimes not-so-subtle) discrimination against women in these male-dominated majors, we have quite a tough task on our hands.

Looking at the historical trends, maybe we have something to learn from Architecture and the Physical Sciences, given that they were in our position only 40 years ago.

Geology, my field of study, has a similar story of declining gender imbalance.

… Between 1974 and 2000, geoscience degrees awarded to women rose from ~17% to 45% (AGI, 2001).

How did it happen?

Interestingly, the rise in women pursuing geoscience degrees coincided with a sharp decline in oil prices that decimated high-paying oil industry opportunities for geologists.  At the same time, an increased interest in environmental issues pushed up the need for geologists to work in that area, often at jobs paid by government dollars either directly or indirectly.  I think more women are attracted to those types of jobs than to the more rough-and-tumble ones in the oil or mining industries.  I don’t see the possibility of a similar change in computer science or engineering where women would become newly attracted to those fields, thus shrinking the current gender gap.

Among the comments at Olson’s post was a suggestion that more female mentors were needed.   And there was this:

When computer science programs incorporate soft skill training into the course content, i.e. communication, inclusion in a group, importance of teamwork, sexual harassment etc, you will see a change. Women have to see what the possibilities are for them in a field long term. If what they are seeing is a male dominated field, with people who do not communicate well, and who do not welcome them to the table, I don’t blame them for not choosing computer science. Women want to work where they are welcomed, where they can use both right and left brain skills.

Extensive group work and writing about math are examples of “soft” skills recently introduced in K-12 education, at least partly implemented as a means of improving the achievement levels of girls in math.  I don’t believe the overall outcomes of this experimentation have been particularly positive, but perhaps it would work better at the college level.

———

Randy Olson, “Percentage of Bachelor’s degrees conferred to women, by major (1970-2012)”, Randal S. Olson, June 14, 2014.

Dallas D. Rhodes, “Generational and Cyclical Demographic Change in The Geological Society of America”, GSA Today, November 2008.

About these ads

4 Comments to “It’s not really a STEM gender gap, but a ‘TE’ gender gap”

  1. The fascinating thing is that the reverse happened in computer science – the number of women majoring the field has DECLINED over time. Back when I got my degree, about 40% of the majors in my department were women. Even in grad school, about a third of the students were women – and that was in a hardcore engineering school program. The decline started in the 80’s. I believe, and others agree with this idea, that it started when PCs were introduced. What had been a very communal, social major turned into the current code-alone-in-your-dorm-room major. The rise of gaming culture has also had a severe impact, as has the idea that software developers should keep crazy hours.

    Back when I majored in CS, I worked as a (paid) intern with a software group at a big hospital. The group was all female except for the sysadmin. They were all women who had majored in math and didn’t want to teach school. CS then was seen as a nice stable, family friendly field, similar to accounting. Boy have things changed!

    Like

  2. 48% of gamers are female, according to one source. But that doesn’t seem to entice women into CS as it does males, or maybe it does.

    Women tend to prefer “communal, social” jobs.

    Like

  3. At UCSC at least, the gender imbalance is larger in the game design major than in computer science as a whole.

    Based on the historical graph shown here, the bursting of the dot-com bubble had a lot to do with the drop of female participation in CS.

    Like

  4. The only way they are getting a number like 48% is by counting the people who play Farmville and Angry Birds as “gamers”. If you take a look at the world of real gamers, I think you will see very different numbers. I don’t think playing Angry Birds while waiting in a supermarket line leads to the kind of engagement that would bring people into CS. Most people think CS is filled with hardcore gamers – greasy pimply boys who stay up all night on their high powered game machines. And you know what? They are right :-)

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 179 other followers

%d bloggers like this: